CCW Check-In (Informal Mode?)

Cameras off, but the world is watching.

This is Anna Hehir, FLI’s Head of Military AI Governance, Éle Donegan, Military AI Fellow, Maggie Munro, Communications Strategist, and Ann Deer, UN Engagement Lead here with The Autonomous Weapons Newsletter. We’re bringing you the news on autonomous weapons systems (AWS) at a pivotal moment, as the world comes to terms with whether algorithms should make life and death decisions (spoiler: most people are terrified).

With this publication, we’re keeping our audience - primarily consisting of policymakers, journalists, and diplomats - up-to-date on the military AI space, covering policymaking efforts, weapons systems technology, and more.

That being said, if you have no idea what we’re talking about, check out autonomousweapons.org for our starter guide on the topic.

If you’ve enjoyed reading this, please be sure to subscribe and share as widely as possible.

Informally informal

As those who have been keeping an eye on the Geneva talks would know, states have yet to agree on the rules of procedure and so the Review Conference to the CCW has yet to officially begin. This procedural impasse is a product of the Russian Federation protesting the presence of observers. Since states cannot agree on procedure formally, no issues of substance have been discussed on the record. Informally, states and observers (including civil society) have been discussing a potential mandate on autonomous weapons all day Tuesday and Wednesday morning, while an impressive lineup of media outlets watch on.

As we write this, states are starting to meet informally informally (not a typo) — behind closed doors, after 7pm, no observers, no civil society present, no press, no interpreters.

The UN Live TV cameras have been off since Monday (we know you’re all devastated to not be able to watch on your favorite channel) but the mics have been on, and we’ve been in the room listening alongside many others. Here’s a quick (informal?) summary:

  • A group of 7 states - Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand, Panama - submitted a working paper calling for a legally binding protocol to be negotiated by the end of 2027.

  • The African Group called for a legally binding protocol to be negotiated by the end of 2028.

  • The Arab Group called for a legally binding protocol in a time bound period.

  • The Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) Group called for a legally binding protocol.

  • According to the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots count from the past two days of individual and group interventions, 139 countries have expressed being open to, or in support of, a mandate on a protocol.

  • There have also been some superstar statements, which we’ve highlighted on our Instagram. We’ll be doing this every day, so stay tuned.

Instagram Post
Instagram Post

Overheard this week

As stated by Kazakhstan on Wednesday, there is a clear, growing cross-regional majority calling for a legally binding protocol to be negotiated as quickly as possible.

As was also rightly pointed out, some states are hiding behind complicated diplomatic language. To those outside the room, “non-legally binding instrument with binding elements” means literally nothing. If it’s a non-legally binding instrument, it’s a non-legally binding instrument.

For those who don’t speak fluent diplomatic legalese, this is described by states as an “instrument without prejudging its nature”.

📃 🔏 To be very very clear, THIS is what needs to happen, as supported by a majority of states, CSOs, faith leaders, and the general public (see our recent polling from the UK, France, and Germany ) 📃 🔏:

✅ Legally-binding instrument

OR

✅ Protocol

OR

✅ Treaty

NOT:

❌ “Further discussions”

❌ “Non-legally binding instrument”

❌ “Instrument without prejudging its nature”

❌ We’re hearing things about a “hybrid instrument”… if this legally-binding and somehow not-legally-binding hybrid is anything like our work from home/office “hybrid” arrangement, it can’t be trusted. We know you turn off your Zoom camera to scroll too.

Previous treaty negotiating mandates (ahem, UN Plastics Pollution treaty negotiations) that included both legally-binding and non-legally binding in the mandate have not gone well.

Media round-up

Consider this our typical ‘What we’re reading and watching’, on steroids.

Eyes are on the CCW. There’s been news coverage from every region of the world, in every form of media — from viral Instagram reels to op-eds from former heads of state (shout-out Helen Clark). We have included as many as we can in daily media round-ups to those taking part in the CCW. See below, for a snapshot of just one day of press coverage from this week.

Print media

International/Regional outlets

National outlets

Digital Media

Here’s a standout piece of content that has gone viral in the past day alone:

Instagram Post

We have been following Alžběta’s content for a while, featuring her work in our previous newsletter.

Want to share?

We’re including some graphics below with sample text, if you’d like to share key information and spread the word to your social networks. You can find several more ready-to-share posts here.

Nearly 9 in 10 people back a treaty on AI weapons.
The public has made up its mind.
Now it's on our leaders.

Landmines. Cluster bombs. Blinding lasers.
Each time, the world agreed some weapons cross a line.
AI weapons are next.

That’s all from us this edition. Short, sweet, and informal!

Stay tuned for what comes next!

Contact us

For tips or feedback, don’t hesitate to reach out to us at [email protected].